Monday, 3 February 2014

Stanley; the dominant and the control freak

A Streetcar named Desire's Stanley Kowalski is a man consumed by the need to control. He holds a lot of power over his recessive wife Stella, who has an undying love for him. Or is it love? I think more desire.

Though Stella claims to "nearly go wild when he's away for a week" and "cry on his lap like a baby when he comes back" (Scene one - page 19), I am not certain that she loves Stanley. She puts up with his rude and disrespectful gestures towards her. For example, in Scene one, on page 4, he 'throws his meat at her,' meaning for it to be a sexual innuendo toward her. What kind of husband throws food at his cherished wife, as if she were an animal, if he loves her? Like the title suggests, desire is what drives the relationship between these two. I think this is one of the things that is the root of Stanley's control. He has this woman who would do anything for him at anytime and he knows this. He takes complete advantage of the things Stella does for him. Stella even allows him to slap her straight across her face, in the drunk state that he was, yet still jump his arms that same night - and later that night, into bed with him. I do not think Stanley Kowalski is capable of loving a woman because he thinks he is so much more powerful and important than they are. I think this man is driven by sexual desire and it consumes him, making him an abusive, angry man.

When Mr. Kowalski hears about the loss of the land of Belle Reve, owned by his wife's family, he is very suspicious. He goes on and on about the Napoleonic Code that he knows so much about. He jumps to the conclusion that Blanche, his sister-in-law, lied about its loss and rather, took all of the money for herself. Being the selfish, controlling man he is, he tells Stella that Blanche must have taken the money for herself and insists that she query her about it because "what's Stella's is his and if there is money hidden somewhere, he wants it because it is so rightfully his." He hates Blanche and thinks she is a compulsive liar. He eventually rapes her, being the beast he is, which I think gives him the impression that he is even more sexually powerful over women. I think Stanley is an evil character and I cannot relate to his character in any way because I detest his morals. He puts himself on a pedestal and treats women, especially his wife, as if they are lower than him.

3 comments:

  1. The way in which I suggested that I could related to Stanley was that it would be challenging to have your sister in law you've never met before especially one in the mental state Blanche is in to move into your home. Blanche basically invades their home, drinks his alcohol, is living off their money and changing an environment that he used to be very familiar with. Do you find that you could relate, even if on a very small scale, to the frustration Stanley must have felt? Is there a time when you've felt frustrated by someone's presence ruining you peace?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes I definitely have felt frustrated by others when I felt that my peace was being disturbed. I understand where you are coming from but I personally dislike Stanley on a very high scale. I detest his controlling personality and even though he is not a real character and neither is Stella, I hate the way he treats her. The sad thing is that there are men like Stanley in the world and there are women like Stella who have to deal with these men. I anything, I commend you for relating to Stanley because it shows your ability to care for those who do not deserve it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you Melanie. No "man" should ever treat a woman like he does, EVER! A woman wants to feel protected, safe, loved, and cared for. How can Stella feel this way if he acts the way he does towards her on a daily basis? I find it sick actually that Stella would even put up with that. I question Stella's view on her self-worth, maybe she is insecure or lonely and feels she won't meet anyone else? Who knows. As far as I'm concerned, she should have left him the first time he did something utterly rude to her, no matter how much she loves him.

    ReplyDelete